6424 Ny-23a, Tannersville

Tucked away down a long private driveway and hidden completely from the road lies one of the best-kept secrets in the Tannersville/Hunter area -- a truly one-of-a-kind custom-built estate set on over 14 wooded acres in the heart of the Catskills. Offering the rare combination of total privacy and incredible convenience, this remarkable property sits just moments from the village of Tannersville, Hunter Mountain, restaurants, golf, hiking, skiing, and year-round recreation -- yet once you arrive, you feel worlds away.

Adding to the property's appeal, there is also an opportunity to purchase a separate adjoining 3+ acre parcel located on highly visible Main Street with access to municipal water and sewer for an additional 299,000. Whether utilized for future development, investment potential, expansion, or additional privacy, opportunities like this in such a prime location are increasingly rare.

As you wind up the wooded driveway, the trees open to reveal this stately home -- a warm and character-filled retreat designed with intention, craftsmanship, and soul. Inside, over 3,870 square feet of living space blend timeless architectural details with inviting mountain comfort. Dark stained exposed beams contrast beautifully against crisp white walls, while arched doorways, pine-clad accents, and rich textures create an atmosphere that feels both sophisticated and relaxed. At the heart of the home, a stunning locally sourced stone wall with a wood-burning insert anchors the open-concept kitchen, dining, and living areas, creating the perfect gathering space for entertaining or cozy evenings after a day of outdoor activities. Sliding glass doors just off the main living areas provide effortless indoor/outdoor flow, leading to an expansive stone patio ideal for peaceful alfresco dining surrounded by nature.

The home offers a total of five bedrooms and three full bathrooms including a second floor en-suite. A dramatic family room filled with natural light serves as a striking centerpiece of the home, while the tremendous, finished flex space above the attached two-car garage offers endless versatility as a home office, art or yoga studio, bunk room, media room, or guest overflow space. A mud/ski room off the garage is perfectly suited for storing ski, biking, hiking, and golf gear, with all four-season activities just moments away. Additional features include a carport, attached two-car garage, beautiful open lawn areas, and ample room for a future pool if desired.

With Hunter Mountain nearby, walkability to vibrant Main Street Tannersville, total seclusion, timeless architectural character, and the added opportunity to acquire an adjoining parcel with municipal utilities, this is far more than a home -- it is a legacy property offering privacy, flexibility, location, and future potential in one extraordinary Catskills setting.
A 3D Walkthrough Tour is available in the digital Lookbook or by request.

Properties for Sale Similar to 6424 Ny-23a, Tannersville, NY

5759 New York 23a, Tannersville

$875,000 - 9 Beds, 10 Baths, 6,000 Sf

MLS® # 20261688

98 Spruce Street, Tannersville

$829,000 - 10 Beds, 4 Baths, 2,842 Sf

MLS® # 20260850

641 N North Lake Road Road, Tannersville

$999,000 - 3 Beds, 2 Baths, 1,568 Sf

MLS® # 20253187